Introduction
Domestic animals react to stress by an alteration of behavioral and physiological responses, which are the results of individual emotional reactivity (
Deiss et al., 2009- Deiss V.
- Temple D.
- Ligout S.
- Racine C.
- Bouix J.
- Terlouw C.
- Boissy A.
Can emotional reactivity predict stress responses at slaughter in sheep?.
). The first response to stress is the behavioral one, which can be considered the cheapest response in terms of the biological cost for the animal (
). The physiological response to stress includes activation of the central nervous system and the endocrine and immune systems, and it can affect the animal's production performance. In sheep, different studies demonstrated the worsening of production performance in response to stressful management procedures (
Sevi et al., 2001a- Sevi A.
- Annicchiarico G.
- Albenzio M.
- Taibi L.
- Muscio A.
- Dell’Aquila S.
Effects of solar radiation and feeding time on behavior, immune response and production of lactating ewes under high ambient temperature.
,
Sevi et al., 2001b- Sevi A.
- Taibi L.
- Albenzio M.
- Muscio A.
- Dell’Aquila S.
- Napolitano F.
Behavioral, adrenal, immune, and productive responses of lactating ewes to regrouping and relocation.
;
Caroprese et al., 2009- Caroprese M.
- Annicchiarico G.
- Schena L.
- Muscio A.
- Migliore R.
- Sevi A.
Influence of space allowance and housing conditions on the welfare, immune response and production performance of dairy ewes.
). The central nervous and immune systems are connected through the activation of the autonomic nervous system and the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (
HPA) axis by the secretion of numerous molecules such as neuropeptides and neurohormones, which are responsible for changes in cellular and humoral immune responses (
Borghetti et al., 2009- Borghetti P.
- Saleri R.
- Mocchegiani E.
- Corradi A.
- Martelli P.
Infection, immunity and the neuroendocrine response.
). In animals and humans, an increase of proinflammatory cytokines, which can give a very early prediction of ongoing stress, has been observed after acute psychological stress (
Black, 2002Stress and the inflammatory response: A review of neurogenic inflammation.
). Stress-induced hypercortisolemia can affect the number of circulating lymphocytes (
;
Dhabhar et al., 1996- Dhabhar F.S.
- Miller A.H.
- McEwes B.S.
- Spencer R.L.
Stress-induced changes in leukocyte distribution: Role of adrenal steroid hormones.
,
Dhabhar, 2009Enhancing versus suppressive effects of stress on immune function: Implications for immunoprotection and immunopathology.
). Fluctuations in the number and percentage of peripheral blood lymphocytes and T-lymphocyte subsets have an effect on animal immunocompetence. The T-helper (
CD4+) cells can activate both humoral and cell-mediated immunity (
Day, 2000Biology of Lymphocytes and Plasma Cells.
), whereas T-cytotoxic (
CD8+) cells are involved in the immune surveillance of peripheral tissues and in the elimination of pathogens (
Park et al., 1992- Park Y.H.
- Fox L.K.
- Hamilton M.J.
- Daws W.C.
Bovine mononuclear leukocyte subpopulations in peripheral blood and mammary gland secretions during lactation.
;
Mehrzad et al., 2008- Mehrzad J.
- Janssen D.
- Duchateau L.
- Burvenich C.
Increase in Escherichia coli inoculum dose accelerates CD8+ T-cell trafficking in the primiparous bovine mammary gland.
). Shifts in T-cell subsets can affect the activity of other immune cells and their secretions, thus affecting susceptibility to clinical or subclinical diseases (
Mehrzad et al., 2008- Mehrzad J.
- Janssen D.
- Duchateau L.
- Burvenich C.
Increase in Escherichia coli inoculum dose accelerates CD8+ T-cell trafficking in the primiparous bovine mammary gland.
). Consequently, an animal's response to stress, in terms of cytokine secretion and lymphocyte distribution, may affect its predisposition to disease or stress-related pathologies.
In human and animal studies, the existence of individuals within a population of conspecifics with different stress-reaction patterns has been demonstrated (
Koolhaas et al., 1999- Koolhaas J.M.
- Korte S.M.
- De Boer S.F.
- Van Der Vegt B.J.
- Van Reenen C.G.
- Hopster H.
- De Jong I.C.
- Ruie M.A.W.
- Blokhuis H.J.
Coping styles in animals: Current status in behavior and stress-physiology.
;
Kunz-Ebrecht et al., 2003- Kunz-Ebrecht S.R.
- Mohamed-Ali V.
- Feldman P.J.
- Kirschbaum C.
- Steptoe A.
Cortisol responses to mild psychological stress associated with proinflammatory cytokines.
). Cows with a strong adrenocortical response to isolation showed a larger reduction in the number of peripheral blood lymphocyte than cows with a weak adrenocortical response during endotoxin-induced mastitis (
Hopster et al., 1998- Hopster H.
- van der Werf J.T.N.
- Blokhuis H.J.
Stress enhanced reduction in peripheral blood lymphocyte numbers in dairy cows during endotoxin-induced mastitis.
). As a result, individual differences in stress reactivity may play a role in the animal's ability to face aversive situations and to cope with immunological challenges.
Assessment of animal well-being requires procedures that can be stressful for animals. Several studies have been conducted to determine welfare indicators in biological fluids other than blood, such as milk cortisol (
Verkerk et al., 1998- Verkerk G.A.
- Phipps A.M.
- Carragher J.F.
- Matthews L.R.
- Stelwagen K.
Characterization of milk cortisol concentrations as a measure of short-term stress responses in lactating dairy cows.
), salivary cortisol (
Fell et al., 1985- Fell L.R.
- Shutt D.A.
- Bentley C.J.
Development of a salivary cortisol method for detecting changes in plasma “free” cortisol arising from acute stress in sheep.
;
Negrão et al., 2004- Negrão J.A.
- Porcionato M.A.
- de Passillé A.M.
- Rushen J.
Cortisol in saliva and plasma of cattle after ACTH administration and milking.
), milk-antigen-specific IgG concentrations (
Caroprese et al., 2006a- Caroprese M.
- Albenzio M.
- Annicchiarico G.
- Sevi A.
Changes occurring in immune responsiveness of single- and twin-bearing Comisana ewes during the transition period.
,
Caroprese et al., 2006b- Caroprese M.
- Albenzio M.
- Muscio A.
- Sevi A.
Relationship between welfare and udder health indicators in dairy ewes.
), and milk amyloid A (
Winter et al., 2006- Winter P.
- Miny M.
- Fuchs K.
- Baumgartner W.
The potential of measuring serum amyloid A in individual ewe milk and in farm bulk milk for monitoring udder health on sheep dairy farms.
). To our knowledge, no studies have monitored immunological and endocrine parameters in milk under routine milking.
The aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between differing degrees of adrenocortical response to stressful procedures and behavioral responses, immune functions, and the production performance of dairy ewes.
Discussion
Physiological responses of animals to stress are often correlated with their behavioral responses (
Rushen, 2000Some issues in the interpretation of behavioural responses to stress.
). The set of physiological and behavioral responses to stress defines a passive response to aversive conditions, characterized by high HPA axis reactivity and low sympathetic reactivity (e.g., low heart rate and cathecolamine secretion). On the contrary, an active response is characterized by low HPA axis reactivity and high sympathetic reactivity (
Koolhaas et al., 1999- Koolhaas J.M.
- Korte S.M.
- De Boer S.F.
- Van Der Vegt B.J.
- Van Reenen C.G.
- Hopster H.
- De Jong I.C.
- Ruie M.A.W.
- Blokhuis H.J.
Coping styles in animals: Current status in behavior and stress-physiology.
). The short duration of movement and low number of bleats recorded in dairy ewes characterized by a high cortisol concentration after the isolation test indicate a passive coping style, which highlights a relationship between high HPA axis reactivity and withdrawal behavior. The behavioral parameters registered in the LC ewes can typically be considered an active behavioral pattern, confirming the aforementioned hypothesis. Some researchers (
Napolitano et al., 2003- Napolitano F.
- Annicchiarico G.
- Caroprese M.
- De Rosa G.
- Taibi L.
- Sevi A.
Lambs prevented from suckling their mothers displayed behavioral, immune, and endocrine disturbances.
;
Sevi et al., 2003- Sevi A.
- Caroprese M.
- Annicchiarico G.
- Albenzio M.
- Taibi L.
- Muscio A.
The effect of a gradual separation from the mother on later behavioral, immune and endocrine alterations in artificially reared lambs.
) found that stressful management practices resulted in a withdrawal behavior in sheep isolated in a novel environment.
Both physiological and psychological stressors can determine the secretion of proinflammatory cytokines IL-1β, IL-6, and tumor necrosis factor-α; in turn, cytokine production and actions are controlled by cortisol (
Black, 2002Stress and the inflammatory response: A review of neurogenic inflammation.
;
Caroprese et al., 2006a- Caroprese M.
- Albenzio M.
- Annicchiarico G.
- Sevi A.
Changes occurring in immune responsiveness of single- and twin-bearing Comisana ewes during the transition period.
). Results from this study demonstrate that differences in cortisol responsiveness are associated with different patterns of plasma IL-1β. In this experiment, HC ewes exhibited higher levels of plasma IL-1β than did LC ewes, supporting the hypothesis that sheep with a hyperactive HPA axis have a high immunological reactivity that could increase inflammatory responses. Interleukin-1β is a very powerful inflammatory cytokine whose expression, synthesis, secretion, and activity are tightly regulated events (
). The direct relationship found between plasma cortisol and cytokine concentration is in contrast with previous findings reported in humans subjected to mild psychological stress by
Kunz-Ebrecht et al., 2003- Kunz-Ebrecht S.R.
- Mohamed-Ali V.
- Feldman P.J.
- Kirschbaum C.
- Steptoe A.
Cortisol responses to mild psychological stress associated with proinflammatory cytokines.
. Those authors found that the cortisol responder group showed lower levels of proinflammatory cytokines than the cortisol nonresponder group. It has been hypothesized, however, that cortisol could stimulate or inhibit immune responses depending on its concentration. In addition, evidence suggests that chronic stress can reduce the suppressive effects of cortisol on immune functions and induce an enhancement of inflammatory responses (
McEwen et al., 1997- McEwen B.S.
- Biron C.A.
- Brunson K.W.
- Bulloch K.
- Chambers W.H.
- Dhabhar F.S.
- Goldfarb R.H.
- Kitson R.P.
- Miller A.H.
- Spencer R.L.
- Weiss J.M.
The role of adrenocorticoids as modulators of immune function in health and disease: Neural, endocrine and immune interactions.
;
McEwen, 1998Protective and damaging effects of stress medicine.
). In line with the profile of proinflammatory cytokines, it was observed that ewes displaying active reactions during the behavioral test had low levels of cytokines, whereas ewes displaying withdrawal behavior had high levels of cytokines. Evidence exists that proinflammatory cytokines induce “sickness behavior,” which is characterized by increased sleeping and decreased activity (
Kemeny, 2009Psychobiological responses to social threat: Evolution of a psychological model in psychoneuroimmunology.
).
An appropriate CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio is important to sustain T-cell homeostasis and immune responses. Although no differences emerged for percentages of CD4
+ and CD8
+ cells and lymphocytes between groups, a lower CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio was measured in HC ewes compared with LC ewes. Some researchers (
Park et al., 1992- Park Y.H.
- Fox L.K.
- Hamilton M.J.
- Daws W.C.
Bovine mononuclear leukocyte subpopulations in peripheral blood and mammary gland secretions during lactation.
;
Kimura et al., 1999- Kimura K.
- Goff J.P.
- Kehrli Jr., M.E.
- Harp J.A.
Phenotype analysis of peripheral blood mononuclear cells in periparturient dairy cows.
) reported that a CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio of approximately 2 is indicative of adequate immunocompetence in the bovine; in HC ewes, the CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio was always <2, suggesting an unbalanced distribution between T-cell subsets and confirming that sheep with hyperactive HPA axis have enhanced immunological functions.
Mehrzad et al., 2008- Mehrzad J.
- Janssen D.
- Duchateau L.
- Burvenich C.
Increase in Escherichia coli inoculum dose accelerates CD8+ T-cell trafficking in the primiparous bovine mammary gland.
found a decrease in blood CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio in cows subjected to intramammary challenge with
Escherichia coli, and an increase in CD8
+ cells trafficking in the site of inflammation. In both groups in the current study, the effect of isolation stress on the CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio appeared evident 2 h after isolation, when an increase in the CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio was measured. Previous studies demonstrated that isolation in sheep could result in an increase of CD4
+ cells and of the CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio (
Degabriele and Fell, 2001Changes in behaviour, cortisol and lymphocyte types during isolation and group confinement of sheep.
).
Mehrzad and Zhao, 2008T lymphocyte proliferative capacity and CD4+/CD8+ ratio in primiparous and pluriparous lactating cows.
found an increased proportion of CD4
+ cells and an increased CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio in pluriparous cows, resulting in an immunological dysregulation compared with primiparous cows. Accordingly, our results showed that immune depression and subsequent increased susceptibility to diseases, which are often observed in animals subjected to stress, could be connected to the imbalance in the proportion of T-cell subsets, resulting in a reduced T-cytotoxic immune response. In addition, our findings can be of practical interest by suggesting that the first 5 h after stress exposure are crucial for the recovery of immunological competence; the weakness of immune responses in this period has to be considered when possible exposure to pathogens as well as vaccination programs occur.
One of the objectives of the trial was to find a correlation between blood and milk parameters to use milk indicators as detection tools of immunological functions and physiological stress. Concentrations of proinflammatory cytokines in whey, as well as in plasma, were influenced by the level of cortisol concentrations, being higher in HC than in LC ewes. The lack of correlation between plasma and whey IL-6 is not easy to interpret; a tentative explanation may be found in a circadian release rhythm of IL-6, which has been observed by
Maggio et al., 2006- Maggio M.
- Guralnik J.M.
- Longo D.L.
- Ferrucci L.
Interleukin-6 in aging and chronic disease: A magnificent pathway.
in humans. The secretion pattern of IL-6 together with different times of blood and milk collection could be responsible, at least partly, for different concentrations of IL-6 circulating in the blood and accumulating in the mammary glands of HC and LC ewes and, consequently, for the failure to find differences in the cytokine concentration in plasma. On the contrary, whey IL-6 levels showed differences between the experimental groups, probably because of the reduced sensitivity to IL-6 fluctuations of the mammary gland compartment with respect to blood. The positive correlation found between IL-1β in plasma and in whey could be connected to the type of stressor tested. In a previous study, detectable concentrations of both IL-1β and IL-6 in sheep whey during the transition period were found, but no correlation between cytokine concentrations in whey and blood emerged (
Caroprese et al., 2006a- Caroprese M.
- Albenzio M.
- Annicchiarico G.
- Sevi A.
Changes occurring in immune responsiveness of single- and twin-bearing Comisana ewes during the transition period.
). Thus, we hypothesized that a relationship between blood and milk cytokines exists, depending on the nature and intensity of stress.
Cortisol concentrations in milk and plasma are closely correlated (
). The absence of differences observed in whey cortisol concentrations between groups could be ascribed to time of ewe milking after the action of stress.
Verkerk et al., 1998- Verkerk G.A.
- Phipps A.M.
- Carragher J.F.
- Matthews L.R.
- Stelwagen K.
Characterization of milk cortisol concentrations as a measure of short-term stress responses in lactating dairy cows.
stated that in lactating cows, cortisol measurement in milk can be a useful indicator of acute stressors acting up to 2 h before sampling. The determination of cortisol in milk fails to give an indication of the effect of stressful situations on sheep if milking does not occur soon after the stressor itself.
In sheep, stressful management procedures can affect both milk production and quality, causing an increase in SCC (
Caroprese et al., 2009- Caroprese M.
- Annicchiarico G.
- Schena L.
- Muscio A.
- Migliore R.
- Sevi A.
Influence of space allowance and housing conditions on the welfare, immune response and production performance of dairy ewes.
). In fact, several stressors connected with the activation of HPA and the increased concentration of cortisol have been proven to reduce milk yield (
Varner and Johnson, 1983Influence of adrenocorticotropin hormone upon milk production, milk constituents, and endocrine measures of dairy cows.
;
Hemsworth et al., 2000- Hemsworth P.H.
- Coleman G.J.
- Barnett J.L.
- Borg S.
Relationship between human-animal interaction and productivity of commercial dairy cows.
;
Sevi et al., 2001b- Sevi A.
- Taibi L.
- Albenzio M.
- Muscio A.
- Dell’Aquila S.
- Napolitano F.
Behavioral, adrenal, immune, and productive responses of lactating ewes to regrouping and relocation.
). Ewes with low cortisol concentrations had, on average, a 19% higher milk yield than ewes with high cortisol concentrations. There are several possible explanations for the reduction of milk yield in HC ewes: first, the high levels of cortisol could have reduced the blood glucose availability to the mammary gland. Reduced uptake from blood of lactose precursor could have had a role in reducing milk yield, because lactose is the principal osmoregulatory component in milk. Second, reduced milk yield could be the outcome of reduced blood flow to the mammary gland caused by the increase in catecholamines with impairment of the release and action of oxytocin that has been found in stressed animals (
). Moreover, immunological stressors and the induction of cytokine secretion may affect nutrient partitioning and divert nutrients away from production toward liver anabolism and the host defense mechanism (
). Together with the association between the extent of cortisol concentration and milk yield, a relationship between cortisol concentration and the levels of SCC was found. The higher SCC observed in milk from the HC ewes is not easy to explain. Findings about the relationship between the levels of SCC and stress are contradictory, even if the administration of adrenocorticotropic hormones to lactating cows has been proven to increase SCC and decrease milk production (
Berning et al., 1987- Berning L.M.
- Paape M.J.
- Miller R.H.
- LaDane R.A.
N-acetyl-beta-D-glucosaminidase activities, milk somatic cell counts, and blood leukocyte and erythrocyte counts in cows after heat-induced stress or after intravenous administration of adrenocorticotropic hormone.
). Evidence exists of a close relationship between poor welfare and increased susceptibility to mastitis (
Sevi et al., 2001a- Sevi A.
- Annicchiarico G.
- Albenzio M.
- Taibi L.
- Muscio A.
- Dell’Aquila S.
Effects of solar radiation and feeding time on behavior, immune response and production of lactating ewes under high ambient temperature.
). Recent findings suggest that ewes selected for a low SCC had higher mastitis resistance than ewes with high SCC and demonstrated a greater ability to limit inflammatory processes of the mammary gland and to prevent the clinical consequences of mastitis (
Rupp et al., 2009- Rupp R.
- Bergonier D.
- Dion S.
- Hygonenq M.C.
- Aurel M.R.
- Robert-Granié C.
- Foucras G.
Response to somatic cell count-based selection for mastitis resistance in a divergent selection experiment in sheep.
). Several studies found that behavioral and neuroendocrine responses to stress are genetically mediated and identify distinct phenotypes stable over time (
Hopster et al., 1998- Hopster H.
- van der Werf J.T.N.
- Blokhuis H.J.
Stress enhanced reduction in peripheral blood lymphocyte numbers in dairy cows during endotoxin-induced mastitis.
;
). In addition, a close relationship between the behavioral and neuroendocrine responses to stress and immunity has been stated.
Article info
Publication history
Accepted:
February 23,
2010
Received:
July 30,
2009
Copyright
© 2010 American Dairy Science Association. Published by Elsevier Inc.