INTRODUCTION
Dairy cows are typically fed energy-dense diets rich in highly digestible nonstructural carbohydrates to fulfill their high energy requirements. This type of feeding impairs chewing behavior and most importantly leads to accumulation of large amounts of VFA in the rumen fluid (
). Ruminants need long chewing periods, whereby impaired chewing activity hampers rumen buffering, which, together with the accumulation of large amounts of VFA, lowers ruminal pH, thus increasing the risk of SARA (
Kleen et al., 2003- Kleen J.L.
- Hooijer G.A.
- Rehage J.
- Noordhuizen J.P.
Subacute ruminal acidosis (SARA): A review.
;
Hernández et al., 2014- Hernández J.
- Benedito J.L.
- Abuelo A.
- Castillo C.
Ruminal acidosis in feedlot: From aetiology to prevention.
). Subacute ruminal acidosis is a prevalent health concern, particularly in cows during early lactation, and causes major economic losses to the dairy industry (
Garrett et al., 1997- Garrett E.F.
- Nordlund K.V.
- Goodger W.J.
- Oetzel G.R.
A cross-sectional field study investigating the effect of periparturient dietary management on ruminal pH in early lactation dairy cows.
;
Plaizier et al., 2008- Plaizier J.C.
- Krause D.O.
- Gozho G.N.
- McBride B.W.
Subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cows: The physiological causes, incidence and consequences.
). The severity and duration of SARA conditions are particularly relevant for rumen health (
Khafipour et al., 2009- Khafipour E.
- Li S.
- Plaizier J.C.
- Krause D.O.
Rumen microbiome composition determined using two nutritional models of subacute ruminal acidosis.
;
Schwaiger et al., 2013- Schwaiger T.
- Beauchemin K.A.
- Penner G.B.
Duration of time that beef cattle are fed a high-grain diet affects the recovery from a bout of ruminal acidosis: Short-chain fatty acid and lactate absorption, saliva production, and blood metabolites.
). Recent research of our team observed that intermittent SARA conditions are stronger than persistent SARA conditions, likely because the rumen and its microbiota have less chance to adapt and the VFA are less absorbed across the reticulorumen wall (
Pourazad et al., 2016- Pourazad P.
- Khiaosa-Ard R.
- Qumar M.
- Wetzels S.U.
- Klevenhusen F.
- Metzler-Zebeli B.U.
- Zebeli Q.
Transient feeding of a concentrate-rich diet increases the severity of subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cattle.
;
Qumar et al., 2016- Qumar M.
- Khiaosa-Ard R.
- Pourazad P.
- Wetzels S.
- Klevenhusen F.
- Kandler W.
- Aschenbach J.
- Zebeli Q.
Evidence of in vivo absorption of lactate and modulation of short chain fatty acid absorption from the reticulorumen of non-lactating cattle fed high concentrate diets.
;
Wetzels et al., 2016- Wetzels S.U.
- Mann E.
- Metzler-Zebeli B.U.
- Pourazad P.
- Qumar M.
- Klevenhusen F.
- Pinior B.
- Wagner M.
- Zebeli Q.
- Schmitz-Esser S.
Epimural indicator phylotypes of transiently-induced subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cattle.
). The latter is a major concern, as VFA absorption is essential for the regulation of the intraruminal pH and the alleviation of SARA conditions (
Aschenbach et al., 2011- Aschenbach J.R.
- Penner G.B.
- Stumpff F.
- Gäbel G.
Ruminant nutrition symposium: Role of fermentation acid absorption in the regulation of ruminal pH.
;
Schwaiger et al., 2013- Schwaiger T.
- Beauchemin K.A.
- Penner G.B.
Duration of time that beef cattle are fed a high-grain diet affects the recovery from a bout of ruminal acidosis: Short-chain fatty acid and lactate absorption, saliva production, and blood metabolites.
).
The rumen plays an important role not only in supplying energy and nutrients, but also in modulating the overall health of the cow (
). The SARA has been associated with the initiation of a chain of metabolic and microbial alterations and dysbiosis in the rumen (
Khafipour et al., 2009- Khafipour E.
- Li S.
- Plaizier J.C.
- Krause D.O.
Rumen microbiome composition determined using two nutritional models of subacute ruminal acidosis.
;
Steele et al., 2011- Steele M.A.
- Croom J.
- Kahler M.
- AlZahlal O.
- Hook S.E.
- Plaizier K.
- McBride B.W.
Bovine rumen epithelium undergoes rapid structural adaptations during grain-subacute ruminal acidosis.
), which are implicated in multiple metabolic health disorders in dairy cows. For example, research has shown that cows experiencing SARA are more susceptible to laminitis (
), metabolic disturbances and inflammation (
Plaizier et al., 2008- Plaizier J.C.
- Krause D.O.
- Gozho G.N.
- McBride B.W.
Subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cows: The physiological causes, incidence and consequences.
;
Zebeli et al., 2011- Zebeli Q.
- Dunn S.M.
- Ametaj B.N.
Perturbations of plasma metabolites correlated with the rise of rumen endotoxin in dairy cows fed diets rich in easily degradable carbohydrates.
), milk fat depression syndrome (
Zebeli and Ametaj, 2009Relationship between rumen lipopolysaccharide and mediators of inflammatory response with milk fat production and efficiency in dairy cows.
;
Dong et al., 2014- Dong G.
- Qiu M.
- Ao C.
- Zhou J.
- Khas-Erdene
- Wang X.
- Zhang Z.
- Yang Y.
Feeding a high-concentrate corn straw diet induced epigenetic alterations in the mammary tissue of dairy cows.
), liver abscesses and displaced abomasum, and that these cows suffer often from off-feed and ketosis (
Kleen et al., 2003- Kleen J.L.
- Hooijer G.A.
- Rehage J.
- Noordhuizen J.P.
Subacute ruminal acidosis (SARA): A review.
;
Plaizier et al., 2008- Plaizier J.C.
- Krause D.O.
- Gozho G.N.
- McBride B.W.
Subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cows: The physiological causes, incidence and consequences.
;
Zebeli et al., 2015- Zebeli Q.
- Ghareeb K.
- Humer E.
- Metzler-Zebeli B.U.
- Besenfelder U.
Nutrition, rumen health and inflammation in the transition period and their role on overall health and fertility in dairy cows.
). Thus, cows experiencing SARA might be more susceptible to external infectious stimuli such as those occurring during acute mastitis challenge compared with cows that did not experience SARA conditions. However, the responses in feed intake, chewing behavior, rumen, milk, and clinical variables in cows experiencing SARA conditions to an acute mastitis challenges have not been yet investigated. An accurate model of naturally occurring acute gram-negative mastitis in dairy cows is the experimentally induced single intramammary LPS challenge (
Brooker et al., 1981- Brooker B.E.
- Frost A.J.
- Hill A.W.
At least two toxins are involved in Escherichia coli mastitis.
;
Shuster et al., 1993- Shuster D.E.
- Kehrli M.E.
- Stevens M.G.
Cytokine production during endotoxin-induced mastitis in lactating dairy cows.
).
We hypothesized that cows subjected to an intermittent and long-term SARA feeding regimen (
Pourazad et al., 2016- Pourazad P.
- Khiaosa-Ard R.
- Qumar M.
- Wetzels S.U.
- Klevenhusen F.
- Metzler-Zebeli B.U.
- Zebeli Q.
Transient feeding of a concentrate-rich diet increases the severity of subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cattle.
) and exposed to a single intramammary LPS challenge have lower feed intake, impaired chewing behavior and milk yield, and a stronger response in clinical variables compared with a control group that was not subjected to SARA conditions. This study aimed to investigate the effects of a single intramammary LPS infusion on DMI, chewing activity, rumen pH, and temperature as well as milk variables, and other health parameters such as rectal temperature, pulse rate, and rumen contractions in dairy cows experiencing intermittently induced SARA conditions or not.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Animal, Experimental Design, and Diets
The experimental procedures were approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee of the University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna (Vetmeduni Vienna) and the National Authority of Austria according to §26 of the Law for Animal Experiments, Tierversuchsgesetz 2012-TVG (GZ BMWFW-68.205/0096-WF/V/3b/2015).
The experiment was conducted at the Dairy Research Station of the University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna (Pottenstein, Austria). A total of 18 early lactating Simmental cows (712.3 ± 101.3 kg of BW; 66.6 ± 20.4 DIM; 8 primiparous and 10 multiparous) without a history of mastitis and with a SCC of less than 200,000 cells/mL in all quarters were enrolled in this study. The cows were blocked by DIM and lactation number and assigned to 2 different feeding groups: control (
CON; n = 6) and SARA (n = 12). Cows of the CON group received the same diet throughout the experiment, consisting of a TMR that contained 27% concentrates (DM basis), whereby these cows had additional access to a concentrate mixture for dairy cows at a maximum allowance of 4 kg per cow and day (
Table 1), reaching an overall concentrate level of approximately 40% of the total daily DMI. The SARA feeding regimen was an intermittent concentrate-rich feeding challenge, as adapted from
Pourazad et al., 2016- Pourazad P.
- Khiaosa-Ard R.
- Qumar M.
- Wetzels S.U.
- Klevenhusen F.
- Metzler-Zebeli B.U.
- Zebeli Q.
Transient feeding of a concentrate-rich diet increases the severity of subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cattle.
. This feeding challenge consisted of feeding cows a TMR with 60% concentrate (
Table 1) for 8 d (
SARA 1), switched for 7 d (
SARA break) to the same feeding management as the CON cows, and subsequently stepped up to the 60% concentrate-TMR for the last 17 d of the experiment, whereby the first and the second week of this time were denoted as
SARA 2 and
SARA 3, respectively, and the remaining 3 d were the intramammary LPS challenge.
Table 1Ingredients and nutrient composition of the control and SARA diets
Fresh TMR were mixed daily using a feeding and mixing robot (Triomatic T15, Trioliet Feeding Technology, Oldenzaal, the Netherlands) and offered twice a day (0800 and 1500 h) to the cows in individual electronically regulated feeding troughs (Insentec B.V., Marknesse, the Netherlands). The TMR were available ad libitum, and feed refusals, reaching between 5 and 10% of the offered feed, were removed before offering the fresh feed in the morning. Also, the daily concentrate allowances for cows of the CON group and of the SARA group during the 7-d SARA break were supplied twice, at 1000 and 1600 h, in separate automatic feeding troughs (Insentec B.V.), based on the profile of reticuloruminal pH. This separate and controlled access to concentrate ensured that the respective cows did not experience SARA while meeting their requirements of energy and nutrients. The concentrate refusals were also removed before offering the fresh concentrate in the morning of the next day. The amount of feeds consumed daily was recorded electronically by the feeding troughs.
Diets were formulated according to
guidelines to meet or exceed the energy and nutrient requirements of 700 kg cows producing 35 kg of milk/d with 4.0% fat and 3.4% protein. The cows had free access to water throughout the trial.
Reticuloruminal pH and Temperature and Monitoring of SARA Conditions
Reticuloruminal pH and temperature were measured continuously throughout the experiment using wireless bolus sensors (Smaxtec Animal Care Sales GmbH, Graz, Austria). By using an applicator, these validated bolus sensors (
Klevenhusen et al., 2014- Klevenhusen F.
- Pourazad P.
- Wetzels S.U.
- Qumar M.
- Khol-Parisini M.A.
- Zebeli Q.
Technical note: Evaluation of a real-time wireless pH measurement system relative to intraruminal differences of digesta in dairy cattle.
) were manually administered via the esophagus into the reticulorumen. Prior to their use, the boli were calibrated using a buffer solution at pH 7.0 following the company instructions and were registered to the computer software device afterward. A wireless antenna was installed in the free stall to communicate with the sensors. Both temperature and pH data were received every 10 min from the wireless antenna. Mean pH values as well as the total time of pH below a threshold of 6.0 were calculated throughout the entire experiment. Besides the diurnal temperature dynamics, also the mean, minimum, and maximum temperature as well as the total time and area of temperature above a threshold of 39.5°C were calculated. As the boli are located in the reticulum within 24 h after administration and reticular pH readings are on average 0.24 units higher than ruminal pH readings (
Falk et al., 2016- Falk M.
- Münger A.
- Dohme-Meier F.
Technical note: A comparison of reticular and ruminal pH monitored continuously with 2 measurement systems at different weeks of early lactation.
), the criterion for the occurrence of SARA conditions in this study was a reticuloruminal pH below 6.0 for at least 5 to 6 h/d as recently adapted to
Zebeli et al., 2008- Zebeli Q.
- Dijkstra J.
- Tafaj M.
- Steingass H.
- Ametaj B.N.
- Drochner W.
Modeling the adequacy of dietary fiber in dairy cows based on the responses of ruminal pH and milk fat production to composition of the diet.
in a validation study conducted by V. Neubauer, E. Humer, I. Kroeger, T. Braid, M. Wagner, and Q. Zebeli (Institute of Animal Nutrition and Functional Compounds, Vetmeduni Vienna, Austria).
Intramammary LPS Infusion
The intramammary LPS infusion occurred on d 30 of the experiment, 3 h after the morning milking. Cows were restrained shortly before the infusion, and the teats were cleaned with cotton wool dipped in 70% ethanol (Prima, Spillern, Austria). Thereafter, half of the SARA cows (SARA-LPS) and all CON cows (CON-LPS) received a direct injection of 50 μg LPS from Escherichia coli (O26:B6; Sigma-Aldrich Inc., St. Louis, MO), diluted in 10 mL of sterile NaCl solution (B. Braun, Melsungen, Germany) into the left front quarter using a sterile plastic syringe (BOVIVET Patteansats, Langeskov, Denmark) and wearing sterile gloves. The remaining 6 SARA cows (SARA-PLA) received 10 mL of a sterile NaCl solution as a placebo.
Chewing Activity
The chewing activity was recorded using wireless chewing halters (RumiWatch System, Forschungsanstalt Agroscope Reckenholz-Tänikon, Ettenhausen, Switzerland; ITIN + HOCH GmbH, Fütterungstechnik, Liestal, Switzerland) the day before, as well as during LPS challenge and the following 12 h. The RumiWatch halter, consisting of a noseband sensor with a liquid-filled tube, a pressure tube, a pressure sensor, and a connection cable, recorded the jaw movements of the cows. The raw data were calculated every 1/10 s and saved on a micro SD card attached to the RumiWatch halter. By using the USB reader antenna, the raw data were transferred to the software RumiWatch manager using a wireless system. Furthermore, the data were processed using the software RumiWatch. All measured data were used to compute the time spent eating and ruminating, as well as the total chewing time, the number of boli, the chews per bolus, as well as the chews per minute following the procedures described by
Zehner et al., 2012Zehner, N., J. J. Niederhauser, F. Nydegger, A. Grothmann, M. Keller, M. Hoch, A. Haeussermann, and M. Schick. 2012. Validation of a new health monitoring system (RumiWatch) for combined automatic measurement of rumination, feed intake, water intake and locomotion in dairy cows. Pages 1–6 in International Conference of Agricultural Engineering CIGR. 8-12 July, Publ. Ageng, Valencia, Spain.
.
Clinical Health Parameters
To monitor the clinical status of the cows, rectal temperature, pulse rate, and rumen contractions were measured shortly before, as well as 2, 4, 6, 8, 12, 24, 36, and 48 h after the infusion of LPS. Rectal temperature was measured using a rectal thermometer (Henry Schein Medical, Vienna, Austria) and pulse rate and rumen contractions were measured using a stethoscope.
Feed Sampling and Chemical Analyses
Feed and feed refusal samples were collected once a week for proximate analysis. All analyses were conducted in duplicate according to the German Handbook of Agricultural Experimental and Analytical Methods (
). Prior to analyses, the samples were dried at 65°C for 48 h and ground to pass a 0.5-mm screen afterward (Retsch, Haan, Germany). The DM was determined by drying in an oven at 100°C for 24 h. Ash was analyzed using muffle furnace at a temperature of 580°C overnight. The CP content was determined using the Kjeldahl method and ether extract was assayed using Soxhlet extraction. The NDF and ADF were analyzed following
Van Soest et al., 1991- Van Soest P.J.
- Robertson J.B.
- Lewis B.A.
Methods for dietary fiber, neutral detergent fiber, and nonstarch polysaccharides in relation to animal nutrition.
, with heat stable α-amylase in the NDF procedure and both fiber fractions were expressed exclusive of residual ash. The NFC were computed as NFC = 100 – (CP + NDF + ash + ether extract). The content of NE
L in feeds was estimated according to
.
Milk Data
The cows were milked twice daily, at 0730 and 1730 h, in a tandem milking parlor. Milk yields were noted automatically using an electronic machine recorder (DeLaval Corp., Tumba, Sweden). From d 30 to 32 foremilk samples were manually taken from the left front quarter during the morning and afternoon milking and analyzed separately for SCC, protein, fat, lactose, urea, and pH by Combifoss (Foss, Hillerød, Denmark). Also, before enrolling in the experiment as well as before and after the LPS challenge, the SCC was analyzed. Additionally, udder health was monitored using the California Mastitis Test (SCC <200,000; DeLaval Corp.) at the start of the experiment and following LPS infusion to detect clinical mastitis.
Statistical Analyses
The data were evaluated by ANOVA using the MIXED procedure of SAS (version 9.2, SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC). For each variable tested, the model included the fixed effects of time (i.e., day, hour, minute, or time interval) and group (CON, SARA) or treatment (CON-LPS, SARA-LPS, SARA-PLA), respectively, as well as the interaction time × group/treatment. The measurements carried out on the day before LPS infusions were considered as covariate in the statistical analysis to obtain the effects of the LPS infusion per se. The individual cows were considered as random effects. The data obtained on the same cow but at different times were considered as repeated measurements with a first order autoregressive variance-covariance matrix. The pdiff option was used for each LSM comparison. Furthermore, for assessing the overall effect of the LPS infusion, an orthogonal contrast involving the average of the 2 LPS treatments versus PLA was tested. Differences among LSM with P < 0.05 were considered as representing significant differences, and differences among LSM with 0.05 ≤ P < 0.10 were accepted as representing tendencies.
DISCUSSION
The present study was performed to evaluate the effect of a single intramammary LPS infusion on feed intake, chewing activity, reticuloruminal pH, milk parameters as well as further health-related variables in dairy cows subjected to an intermittent and long-term SARA-feeding regimen before LPS infusion. The SARA regimen consisted in intermittent feeding of 60% concentrate for 8 d, followed by a SARA break for 7 d with the same feeding management as the CON cows, and subsequently stepped up to the 60% concentrate for the remaining 17 d, which resulted in depressed reticuloruminal pH during the feeding challenges, reaching the SARA threshold [
Zebeli et al., 2008- Zebeli Q.
- Dijkstra J.
- Tafaj M.
- Steingass H.
- Ametaj B.N.
- Drochner W.
Modeling the adequacy of dietary fiber in dairy cows based on the responses of ruminal pH and milk fat production to composition of the diet.
; V. Neubauer, E. Humer, I. Kroeger, T. Braid, M. Wagner, and Q. Zebeli (Institute of Animal Nutrition and Functional Compounds, Vetmeduni Vienna, Austria)]. In contrast, the CON cows were fed a moderate but common concentrate level (approximately 40%) in dairy cow feeding, which, as intended, maintained the cows above the threshold of SARA conditions, while meeting their requirements in energy and nutrients. The SARA typically has been associated with a chain of metabolic and microbial alterations in the rumen, adversely affecting rumen and systemic health of the cows (
Plaizier et al., 2008- Plaizier J.C.
- Krause D.O.
- Gozho G.N.
- McBride B.W.
Subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cows: The physiological causes, incidence and consequences.
). Our main hypothesis was that cows experiencing repeated periods of SARA (
Pourazad et al., 2016- Pourazad P.
- Khiaosa-Ard R.
- Qumar M.
- Wetzels S.U.
- Klevenhusen F.
- Metzler-Zebeli B.U.
- Zebeli Q.
Transient feeding of a concentrate-rich diet increases the severity of subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cattle.
) are more responsive to external infectious stimuli due to such alterations in the digestive tract. Indeed, our results demonstrated that a single intramammary LPS challenge led to a faster increase in ruminal temperature as well as a stronger decline in feed intake, chewing activity, and milk yield in cows subjected to an intermittent SARA feeding regimen compared with cows receiving a lower concentrate level continuously.
More specifically, the cows that received an intramammary LPS infusion showed a reduced DMI and chewing activity compared with cows that received an intramammary PLA infusion, whereby cows of the SARA-feeding regimen showed a faster and stronger decline in DMI, total chewing time as well as number of chews per minute and bolus. As eating and ruminating activities in dairy cows are considered as quintessential behaviors, their observation provides helpful information in terms of health conditions (
González et al., 2008- González L.A.
- Tolkamp B.J.
- Coffey M.P.
- Ferret A.
- Kyriazakis I.
Changes in feeding behavior as possible indicators for the automatic monitoring of health disorders in dairy cows.
;
Braun et al., 2013- Braun U.
- Trösch L.
- Nydegger F.
- Hässig M.
Evaluation of eating and rumination behaviour in cows using a noseband pressure sensor.
). The present results can be explained by the pro-inflammatory response to LPS that induces classical signs of sickness behavior that is comparable to cows suffering from acute, clinical mastitis (
Sepúlveda-Varas et al., 2016- Sepúlveda-Varas P.
- Proudfoot K.L.
- Weary D.M.
- von Keyserlingk M.A.G.
Changes in behaviour of dairy cows with clinical mastitis.
). Furthermore, our results are in agreement with previous studies, reporting that intramammary LPS challenge induced obvious clinical symptoms such as decreased DMI only a few hours after infusion of
E. coli (
Fogsgaard et al., 2012- Fogsgaard K.K.
- Røntved C.M.
- Sørensen P.
- Herskin M.S.
Sickness behavior in dairy cows during Escherichia coli mastitis.
;
Lüttgenau et al., 2016- Lüttgenau J.
- Wellnitz O.
- Kradolfer D.
- Kalaitzakis E.
- Ulbrich S.E.
- Bruckmaier R.M.
- Bollwein H.
Intramammary lipopolysaccharide infusion alters gene expression but does not induce lysis of the bovine corpus luteum.
). However, the stronger responsiveness in cows experiencing SARA compared with the control cows is a new finding that deserves further investigations. In a recent study,
Gott et al., 2015- Gott P.N.
- Hogan J.S.
- Weiss W.P.
Effects of various starch feeding regimens on responses of dairy of cows to intramammary lipopolysacccharide infusion.
subjected cows to different starch feeding regimen (control vs. high starch vs. acidosis diets) and intramammary infused 10 μg of LPS (
E. coli O111:B4) after 20 d of feeding the different diets. Although an overall decline in DMI was observed, no difference in the response of the cows of the different feeding regimen was found. Also,
AlZahal et al., 2011- AlZahal O.
- AlZahal H.
- Steele M.A.
- Van Schaik M.
- Kyriazakis I.
- Duffield T.F.
- McBride B.W.
The use of a radiotelemetric ruminal bolus to detect body temperature changes in lactating dairy cattle.
investigated cows receiving diets with a moderate forage:concentrate (52:48 in DM) and high forage:concentrate (65:35 in DM) for 21 d, which were challenged intramammary with 100 μg of LPS (
E. coli O111:B4). Decreasing DMI occurred after LPS infusion but without differing effects among the feeding groups. Possible explanations for the different results in our study compared with previous studies might be due the fact the SARA feeding challenge was long and cows experienced 2 intermittent SARA bouts, which are stronger than a single SARA bout (
Pourazad et al., 2016- Pourazad P.
- Khiaosa-Ard R.
- Qumar M.
- Wetzels S.U.
- Klevenhusen F.
- Metzler-Zebeli B.U.
- Zebeli Q.
Transient feeding of a concentrate-rich diet increases the severity of subacute ruminal acidosis in dairy cattle.
). Also, different doses and serotypes of LPS used might also have contributed to these discrepant results.
In accordance to the DMI, the reduced chewing time due to LPS infusion indicates effects of clinical disease emergence and is in agreement with
Zimov et al., 2011- Zimov J.L.
- Botheras N.A.
- Weiss W.P.
- Hogan J.S.
Associations among behavioral and acute physiologic responses to lipopolysaccharide-induced clinical mastitis in lactating dairy cows.
, who showed that cows spent less time eating and chewing after an intramammary challenge with 25 μg of LPS (
E. coli O6:B26).
Fitzpatrick et al., 2013- Fitzpatrick C.E.
- Chapinal N.
- Petersson-Wolfe C.S.
- DeVries T.J.
- Kelton D.F.
- Duffield T.F.
- Leslie K.E.
The effect of meloxicam on pain sensitivity, rumination time, and clinical signs in dairy cows with endotoxin-induced clinical mastitis.
also observed reduced ruminating time in cows after infusion of 25 μg of LPS derived from
E. coli O111:B4. Despite the general effect of LPS infusion versus PLA, the time spent chewing and the number of boli decreased more strongly in SARA cows receiving LPS compared with CON cows, showing a strong deviation from normal values (
). This finding suggests more pronounced clinical symptoms during experimental
E. coli mastitis in cows experiencing SARA, which might necessitate greater attention and care to restore their feed intake and chewing behavior compared with healthy cows.
Reticuloruminal pH was not affected by intramammary LPS infusion. Similar results have been observed by
AlZahal et al., 2011- AlZahal O.
- AlZahal H.
- Steele M.A.
- Van Schaik M.
- Kyriazakis I.
- Duffield T.F.
- McBride B.W.
The use of a radiotelemetric ruminal bolus to detect body temperature changes in lactating dairy cattle.
, who found no effect of an intramammary infusion of 100 μg of LPS (
E. coli O111:B4) on ruminal pH in cows receiving either a high forage:concentrate TMR or a TMR with a moderate forage:concentrate ratio. The reason might be the decreased DMI observed in cows receiving LPS, which concomitantly decreases fermentation processes. Therefore, a lower production of VFA would be expected to increase ruminal pH; however, one has to consider that ruminal pH is the product of fermentation as well as salivary and mucosal neutralization processes (
Aschenbach et al., 2011- Aschenbach J.R.
- Penner G.B.
- Stumpff F.
- Gäbel G.
Ruminant nutrition symposium: Role of fermentation acid absorption in the regulation of ruminal pH.
). Therefore, the reduced chewing activities in LPS-challenged cows are likely responsible for the missing effect on ruminal pH despite lower DMI.
More importantly, higher ruminal temperature as well as time durations of the temperature above 39.5°C were detected in response to the LPS infusion, whereby SARA-LPS cows responded with a faster temperature rise than their CON counterparts. Although the fever inducing effect of intramammary LPS infusion has been reported in previous studies to be accompanied by rising ruminal temperature (
AlZahal et al., 2011- AlZahal O.
- AlZahal H.
- Steele M.A.
- Van Schaik M.
- Kyriazakis I.
- Duffield T.F.
- McBride B.W.
The use of a radiotelemetric ruminal bolus to detect body temperature changes in lactating dairy cattle.
), the faster response in SARA cows is a new finding that further strengthens our initial hypothesis. In agreement, also a previous study by
AlZahal et al., 2011- AlZahal O.
- AlZahal H.
- Steele M.A.
- Van Schaik M.
- Kyriazakis I.
- Duffield T.F.
- McBride B.W.
The use of a radiotelemetric ruminal bolus to detect body temperature changes in lactating dairy cattle.
demonstrated different responses in certain ruminal temperature variables to an intramammary LPS infusion in cows subjected to different concentrate levels. More specifically, the time duration of ruminal temperature above 38.8°C following LPS challenge was higher in cows subjected to a moderate forage:concentrate diet than in cows receiving a high forage:concentrate diet. However, the exact mechanisms behind some overreaction responses to the LPS challenge in cows subjected to SARA compared with healthy cows are unclear so far and deserve further investigations.
Similar to ruminal temperature, rectal temperature showed a significant increase after LPS infusion with a peak 6 h thereafter as reported before (
Vels et al., 2009- Vels L.
- Røntved C.M.
- Bjerring M.
- Ingvartsen K.L.
Cytokine and acute phase protein gene expression in repeated liver biopsies of dairy cows with a lipopolysaccharide-induced mastitis.
;
Lüttgenau et al., 2016- Lüttgenau J.
- Wellnitz O.
- Kradolfer D.
- Kalaitzakis E.
- Ulbrich S.E.
- Bruckmaier R.M.
- Bollwein H.
Intramammary lipopolysaccharide infusion alters gene expression but does not induce lysis of the bovine corpus luteum.
). An overall high correlation between rectal and ruminal temperature was found in our study, indicating that ruminal temperature measurements are effective in capturing febrile responses of the LPS treatment, as reported previously (
AlZahal et al., 2011- AlZahal O.
- AlZahal H.
- Steele M.A.
- Van Schaik M.
- Kyriazakis I.
- Duffield T.F.
- McBride B.W.
The use of a radiotelemetric ruminal bolus to detect body temperature changes in lactating dairy cattle.
). Unlike ruminal temperature, rectal temperature responses did not differ between SARA-LPS and their CON counterparts. This might be explained by the continuous measurements obtained with the wireless devices, which are more likely to capture changes in the temperature compared with intermittent measurements as conducted rectally. Furthermore, along with increased rectal temperature, pulse rate jumped to abnormal levels 6 and 8 h after LPS infusion (on average 95 beats per min) in cows treated with LPS treatment, but reached normal pulse rates (about 86 beats per minute,
) 12 h thereafter. The peak value of pulse rate coincided with the peak value of rectal temperature (40.5°C) indicating certain stress induced by cortisol changes. In agreement with previous studies, heart rate increased following LPS infusion (
Vels et al., 2009- Vels L.
- Røntved C.M.
- Bjerring M.
- Ingvartsen K.L.
Cytokine and acute phase protein gene expression in repeated liver biopsies of dairy cows with a lipopolysaccharide-induced mastitis.
;
Hagiwara et al., 2014- Hagiwara S.
- Mori K.
- Okada H.
- Oikawa S.
- Nagahata H.
Acute Escherichia coli mastitis in dairy cattle: diagnostic parameters associated with poor prognosis.
;
Lüttgenau et al., 2016- Lüttgenau J.
- Wellnitz O.
- Kradolfer D.
- Kalaitzakis E.
- Ulbrich S.E.
- Bruckmaier R.M.
- Bollwein H.
Intramammary lipopolysaccharide infusion alters gene expression but does not induce lysis of the bovine corpus luteum.
). However, in the present study no alteration of the rumen contractions was found due to LPS infusion. This indicates that intramammary infusion of LPS (
E. coli O26:B6) at a dosage of 50 μg did not induce reticuloruminal stasis, a hazardous sign associated with LPS as an effect of endotoxicosis (
Eades, 1993Endotoxemia in dairy cattle: Role of eicosanoids in reticulorumen stasis.
,
Eades, 1997Endotoxaemia in dairy cattle: Mechanism of reticulorumen stasis.
;
Andersen, 2003Bovine endotoxicosis–Some aspects of relevance to production diseases. A review.
).
Perkins et al., 2002- Perkins K.H.
- VandeHaar M.J.
- Burton J.L.
- Liesman J.S.
- Erskine R.J.
- Elsasser T.H.
Clinical responses to intramammary endotoxin infusion in dairy cows subjected to feed restriction.
observed a decrease in rumen contractions after intramammary LPS (
E. coli O111:B4) infusion at a dosage of 100 μg. However, in agreement with our study
Gott et al., 2015- Gott P.N.
- Hogan J.S.
- Weiss W.P.
Effects of various starch feeding regimens on responses of dairy of cows to intramammary lipopolysacccharide infusion.
observed no changes in rumen motility in cows receiving 10 μg of
E. coli (O111:B4), suggesting dose-dependent responses of this variable.
As shown as a clinical inflammatory sign, the LPS challenge induced a strong increase in SCC (
Wellnitz et al., 2011- Wellnitz O.
- Arnold E.T.
- Bruckmaier R.M.
Lipopolysaccharide and lipoteichoic acid induce different immune responses in the bovine mammary gland.
;
Vernay et al., 2012- Vernay M.C.M.B.
- Wellnitz O.
- Kreipe L.
- Van Dorland H.A.
- Bruckmaier R.M.
Local and systemic response to intramammary lipopolysaccharide challenge during long-term manipulated plasma glucose and insulin concentration in dairy cows.
;
Gott et al., 2015- Gott P.N.
- Hogan J.S.
- Weiss W.P.
Effects of various starch feeding regimens on responses of dairy of cows to intramammary lipopolysacccharide infusion.
). Our findings revealed no difference in SCC between SARA-LPS and CON-LPS cows. Interestingly,
Gott et al., 2015- Gott P.N.
- Hogan J.S.
- Weiss W.P.
Effects of various starch feeding regimens on responses of dairy of cows to intramammary lipopolysacccharide infusion.
found a significantly higher SCC in cows fed control and acidosis (designed to cause acute bouts of ruminal pH depression) diets compared with cows fed high starch (formulated to induce chronic ruminal pH depression) diets after intramammary LPS infusion, thus suggesting a certain endotoxin tolerance at the local level of the mammary gland. Nevertheless, the underlying mechanisms have not been clarified so far.
Furthermore, the observed changes in the milk constituents corroborate the characteristic alterations that have been reported during clinical mastitis (
Shuster et al., 1991- Shuster D.E.
- Harmon R.J.
- Jackson J.A.
- Hemken R.W.
Suppression of milk production during endotoxin-induced mastitis.
;
Auldist et al., 1995- Auldist M.J.
- Coats S.
- Rogers G.L.
- McDowell G.H.
Changes in the composition of milk from healthy and mastitic dairy cows during the lactation cycle.
;
). For instance, increased milk protein concentrations have been observed, likely resulting from the disruption of the mammary epithelia cells that in turn increases influx of blood-borne proteins such as serum albumin and immunoglobulins (
Auldist et al., 1995- Auldist M.J.
- Coats S.
- Rogers G.L.
- McDowell G.H.
Changes in the composition of milk from healthy and mastitic dairy cows during the lactation cycle.
;
). Interestingly, cows subjected to the SARA-LPS treatment responded with a faster and also longer increase in the protein content than their CON-LPS counterparts. Also, milk fat concentrations increased after the LPS infusion, whereas the opposite was noticed for lactose. These findings are supported by previous studies (
Shuster et al., 1991- Shuster D.E.
- Harmon R.J.
- Jackson J.A.
- Hemken R.W.
Suppression of milk production during endotoxin-induced mastitis.
;
Pyorala, 2003Indicators of inflammation in the diagnosis of mastitis.
;
Bruckmaier et al., 2004- Bruckmaier R.M.
- Ontsouka C.E.
- Blum J.W.
Fractionized milk composition in dairy cows with subclinical mastitis.
). In accordance to the milk protein concentration, the differences between the cows that were infused LPS compared with the cows that were infused PLA were longer pronounced in SARA-LPS cows compared with CON-LPS. A possible reason might be that SARA-cows were already subjected to LPS, which might have been translocated from the gastrointestinal tract to the mammary gland (
Dong et al., 2014- Dong G.
- Qiu M.
- Ao C.
- Zhou J.
- Khas-Erdene
- Wang X.
- Zhang Z.
- Yang Y.
Feeding a high-concentrate corn straw diet induced epigenetic alterations in the mammary tissue of dairy cows.
).
Furthermore, a stronger decline in the milk yield in SARA-LPS cows compared with CON-LPS cows after the LPS challenge was found in the present study. In contrast,
AlZahal et al., 2011- AlZahal O.
- AlZahal H.
- Steele M.A.
- Van Schaik M.
- Kyriazakis I.
- Duffield T.F.
- McBride B.W.
The use of a radiotelemetric ruminal bolus to detect body temperature changes in lactating dairy cattle.
and
Gott et al., 2015- Gott P.N.
- Hogan J.S.
- Weiss W.P.
Effects of various starch feeding regimens on responses of dairy of cows to intramammary lipopolysacccharide infusion.
found no difference regarding the decline in milk yield following LPS challenge in dairy cows subjected to different feeding regimen. Although possible reasons for the different results regarding the milk yield between studies are unclear, differences regarding the LPS serotype and dosage as well as diets used might be important factors whether hyperresponsiveness to an external infectious stimuli would occur or not.
Hitherto little research has been conducted on the responsiveness of ruminants to a single LPS challenge after prolonged exposure to low amounts of LPS. The few studies that have been performed to date indicate that the response might differ among animal factors (
Elsasser et al., 1996- Elsasser T.H.
- Richards M.
- Collier R.
- Hartnell G.F.
Physiological responses to repeated endotoxin challenge are selectively affected by recombinant bovine somatotropin administration to calves.
;
Bieniek et al., 1998- Bieniek K.
- Szuster-Ciesielska A.
- Kamińska T.
- Kondracki M.
- Witek M.
- Kandefer-Szerszeń M.
Tumor necrosis factor and interferon activity in the circulation of calves after repeated injection of low doses of lipopolysaccharide.
;
Gott et al., 2015- Gott P.N.
- Hogan J.S.
- Weiss W.P.
Effects of various starch feeding regimens on responses of dairy of cows to intramammary lipopolysacccharide infusion.
). Moreover, it has been reported from human studies that precedent LPS exposure leads to different responses upon subsequent toxic doses of LPS, depending on the doses and exposure duration (
Morris and Li, 2012Molecular mechanisms and pathological consequences of endotoxin tolerance and priming.
). More specifically, low doses can induce a state of endotoxin tolerance to a subsequent exposure to a high dose of LPS, but very low doses can even have an opposite effect (
Ametaj et al., 2012- Ametaj B.N.
- Sivaraman S.
- Dunn S.M.
- Zebeli Q.
Repeated oral administration of lipopolysaccharide from Escherichia coli O111:B4 modulated humoral immune responses in periparturient dairy cows.
;
Petzl et al., 2012- Petzl W.
- Günther J.
- Pfister T.
- Sauter-Louis C.
- Goetze L.
- von Aulock S.
- Hafner-Marx A.
- Schuberth H.J.
- Seyfert H.M.
- Zerbe H.
Lipopolysaccharide pretreatment of the udder protects against experimental Escherichia coli mastitis.
). Lastly, the present findings should be evaluated with further research using different dosages of LPS to distinguish whether cows would experience tolerance or even an overreaction.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors acknowledge W. Pohl, A. Käfer, E. Draxler, G. Erwin, D. Fleischhacker, K. Günther, K. Dienbauer, P. Kanz, and H. Pothmann (Dairy research station Kremesberg at Vetmeduni Vienna) for their help and excellent technical assistance with the animal trial. We thank A. Fengel, K. Wiesböck, and M. Qumar (students at Vetmeduni Vienna) for their help during the experiment. We thank A. Dockner, S. Eisen, S. Sharma, and M. Wild (Institute of Animal Nutrition and Functional Plant Compounds, Vetmeduni Vienna) for their assistance with laboratory analyses and experimental material preparation. We thank the Qualitätslabor Niederösterreich (Gmünd, Austria) for milk analyses. The first author thanks the Austrian Agency for International Cooperation (Österreichischer Austauschdienst, OEAD) in Education and Research, the ASEAN-European Academic University Network (ASEA UNINET) for the PhD program financial support in Austria. We gratefully acknowledge the Vienna Science and Technology Fund (Wiener Wissenschafts-, Forschungs- und Technologiefonds, WWTF) for the support of this research (project D-I.INFLACOW, LS12-010).